Sunday, June 19, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: Undermining the Will of the People

     The government that the Framers gave us for safe-keeping was designed to be protected by the vote of the people.  New laws came from Congress because it had the most accountability to the people of the nation.  If a law was proposed over which a majority of the people objected, the bill was voted down or the legislators were voted out.  Government learned to be responsive to the voice of the people.
      In recent years, special interest groups  have been able to accomplish their goals without the consent of the people.  For example, abortion is not the law of the land because the people voted it so.  Many other issues could also be listed and the people have watched as their voice in moral and political matters has been stripped away.
     How to circumvent the will of the people has been taught at major universities.  Grow government to extraordinary lengths through public debt.  Distribute massive funds for poverty, welfare and healthcare so that the populace becomes dependent on those things.  Promote class warfare and control religion and education.  Collect the guns.  The Federal government becomes an omnipotent, yet uncaring father and freedom is traded for the security provided.
     Power needs to return to the vote of the people.  The government is there to serve the people, not the reverse.  Candidates who advance their agenda behind the scenes rather than opening declaring and debating their goals must be voted out.   This fall, the people must speak clearly by their vote.  Vote for those leaders who believe in being accountable to the people.

Saturday, June 18, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: Freedom of Education

     In 1926, J. Gresham Machen, a professor of New Testament at Princeton, was asked to give testimony before a congressional committee regarding the formation of a Federal Department of Education.  The bill was an attempt, it was said, to provide better education for the nation by making education more efficient.  Dr. Machen was more than troubled.
      In his opening, Dr. Machen mentioned that there were two reasons one might oppose a bill.  The first was because you didn't think it would do what it set out to do.  The other was that the bill had a evil purpose.  Machen said he opposed the bill for the latter reason.  What could be wrong with streamlining education so that it was more efficient?
     "Uniformity in education under central control it seems to me is the worst fate into which any country can fall,"  he said.  The bill assumed that "children of the state must be educated for the benefit of the State; that idiosyncrasies should be avoided and the State should devise that method of education which will best promote the welfare of the State."  Machen was skillfully pointing out that education's sole goal was not to produce good citizens.  Education served the whole populace so that an educated populace could deliver the nation from temptations to tyranny.
     If good citizenship was not the goal of education, what did Machen see?  He saw education as something radically different:  If you read our history as a nation, "you will discover that our notion has been that parents have a right to educate children as they please; that idiosyncrasies should not be avoided; that the State should prevent one group from tyrannizing over another, and that education is essentially not a matter of the State at all."
     Machen believed in unfettered educational competition.  Let the best ideas win in the public square, whether they are sourced in public, private, or charter schools, or in home schools. He wrote:  "I had a great deal rather have confusion in the sphere of education than intellectual and spiritual death."  The conflict of ideas was important in a democracy.  It is where the best ideas would be generated.  Efficency and uniformity remove the voice of dissent from the public square.  Isn't that where the new ideas come from, whether in science or politics, or religion?
     This fall, vote for the candidate who will reverse the imprisonment of education in uniformity under central control.  Vote for the one whose ideas are open to the full scrutiny of the people.

Friday, June 17, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: Vote against "Bread and Circuses"

     As Rome was in decline, public unrest began to rise.  The government in order to quell the populace began to distribute free food and hold huge spectacles for entertainment.  They diverted the attention of the people from the serious concerns of government to selfish personal issues.  Juvenal, a Roman writer and critic, lamented the moral and political decline:  "Two things only the people anxiously desire- bread and circuses."
     It was a flaw in the character of the people to fall for the diversion.  Our own nation has its own experience with this diversion.  Rebates on taxes whether we paid them or not, cash-for-clunkers, and the promise of thousands of dollars to purchase a first home.  These promises hope to divert the attention of the people from the real issues of a nation.  They also help to curry favor for the giver of such gifts.
    A Scottish judge, writer, and historian saw a dangerous cycle in the distribution of public gifts.  Alexander Fraser Tytler wrote,  “A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largesse from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates promising the most benefits from the public treasury with the result that a democracy always collapses over loose fiscal policy, always followed by a dictatorship. The average age of the world's greatest civilizations has been 200 years. These nations have progressed through this sequence: From bondage to spiritual faith; From spiritual faith to great courage; From courage to liberty; From liberty to abundance; From abundance to selfishness; From selfishness to apathy; From apathy to dependence; From dependence back into bondage.”
      The Framers put their faith in the common people to protect their liberties by being vigilant to watch public officials in their spending of public monies.  They viewed public debt as a public curse (James Madison).  To Jefferson, public debt was one of the greatest dangers to be feared:  "I am not among those who fear the people.  They, not the rich, are our dependence for continued freedom.  And to preserve their independence, we must not let our rulers load us with perpetual debt.  We must make our election between economy and liberty or profusion and servitude."
     This fall, do not vote for the one who will give you the most favors from the public treasury.  Vote for the one who has real ideas about cutting public debt. 

Thursday, June 16, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: How Should We Interpret the Constitution?

     Stephen Breyer and Antonin Scalia used to hold debates on college campuses regarding the Constitution.  Specifically, they wanted the students to understand their differing approaches to interpreting the constitution.  Scalia was an originalist.  He believed the Constitution needed to be understood in light of its original intent.  Breyer was a loose constructionist.  He believes that the Constitution is a living document to be used as a legal guide to the changing needs of society.
     As an originalist, Scalia believed that if the constitution addressed an issue and he didn't like it, it was too bad.  He was chained to the original meaning of the text.  Using due process as an example, he wrote:  "Whereas if you say due process of law is an invitation for intelligent judges and lawyers and law students to imagine what they consider to be due process and consult foreign judges, then, indeed, you do not know what you are saying when you swear to uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States."
     As a loose constructionist, Stephen Breyer believes the interpretation of the constitution should bend to fit the needs of an evolving society.  He consults American and foreign jurisprudence for help in deciding cases. While he admits that it would be wrong for a judge to substitute his own judgment for the Constitution or for the legislature,  he admits it can be a danger.  "The greater danger is the danger of the unelected judge as a decision-maker for the elected parliamentarian congress-- member of congress.  And I think there is no way, actually, to resolve that."
     In our republic, we have a danger of one branch or another overstepping its boundaries.  In this case, Breyer sees the error of a judicial decision carrying the force of law, yet believes it cannot be avoided.  How does that work?
      Before the Roe v. Wade decision, abortion was illegal in all 50 states.  When the court found a right to abortion in the right to privacy, the judgment of all federal and state legislatures was summarily dismissed.  The same was true in the case of Gay Marriage.  A court case opened the door to gay marriage without the approval of one official elected by the people.
     Advocacy groups have turned to the courts to progress their agenda.  It is easier to advance your cause through a court system with the hubris to trust their own judgment than to convince a legislature that must go home to face its electorate.
     Scalia was right.  We will miss his voice of reason on the court.  This fall, elect a president who understands the dangers inherent in loose construction of the constitution.


Wednesday, June 15, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: Can We Legislate Morality?

     Whenever government debates a social issue, there is always the objection proposed that you can't legislate morality.  If by that, it is meant that you can't make a person or society do the right thing, I agree.  The schoolboy forced to sit in his chair will always exclaim, "But I'm standing up on the inside."
     In another sense, every law is an attempt to legislate morality.  If I pass a law about red lights, I am saying that for the good of all involved, I need to curb my right to drive how I please.  It becomes immoral to run the red light and endanger others.  I pay taxes because I have a moral responsibility to provide for a government that can allow us to live trustfully near our neighbor.  To refuse to pay taxes is a moral concern.  When I propose an increase in property taxes, I am saying it is morally right to take more money from the private property of my neighbor to meet my concern.  Do you see how every law has moral implications?
     It is to a government's benefit to write laws that are in keeping with an objective morality.  A law against abortion is a law that regards human life as sacred.  People learn to respect other life as well, including the disabled and the aged.  It is in society's interest to write laws that uphold morality.
     A generation or two of relativism has left us in a moral shambles.  Pluralism has added the attitude that you have no right to impose your morality on me.  As a result, government is impotent to address any moral concern that is not politically correct- which is to say, any moral concern supported by the spirit of the age.  That said, those candidates who adhere courageously to an objective morality deserve our vote this fall.  They are the salt preserving our culture.

Tuesday, June 14, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: How Do We Address Injustice?

     Edmund Burke, English statesman and political theorist, supported the American cause in the British parliament, but opposed the revolution brewing in France.  Because of this, his detractors like Randall Price, charged him with inconsistency.  One good revolution is as good as another.
     Burke responded, in his Reflections on the Revolution in France, that there was a key difference between the two revolutions.  In America, the colonists had worked for years to redress their grievances.  They lived within their rights and responsibilities as British citizens until it was obvious that the king was not upholding his end of their charter.  In contract law, if the king did not fulfill his duties, the contract was void.  The colonies remained within the rule of law until theydeclared breach of contract and moved toward independence.
     In France, however, Burke saw something else.  The complaints of the citizens were real.  The aristocracy was unresponsive.  In pursuing justice, the French populace overthrew the rule of law in order to establish something new.  Burke predicted that one governmental system would fall to the next until such instability resulted in the nation that the people would clamor for a dictator.  A tyrant has the power to provide security amid chaos.  Enter Napoleon.
     There are many injustices to be corrected in American culture.  Drug sentences are notoriously unequal with much longer sentences given to black men.  Systemic racism keeps communities in poverty generation after generation.  Corporate and government corruption continues to grow.  For young idealistic Americans, correcting these injustices is a worthwhile life's work.
     The Framers of our constitution knew there would perpetually be pockets of injustice in our country.  The very first right they enumerated in the Bill of Rights included the right to assemble and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.  They provided ways to fix those injustices without destroying the foundations of our country.  Today's revolutionaries would do well to consider the consequences of overturning the rule of law as they address their grievances.
     William Wilberforce worked within the rule of law to address the abolition of slavery.  For 40 years, he spoke, advocated, and proposed legislation to deal with that stain of slavery on the English nation.  Finally, after 40 years, Parliament abolished slavery in the British empire.  The movie Amazing Grace tells the story.  When the final vote was announced, everyone applauds Wilberforce for his perseverance.  And there was no civil war.
     This fall, vote for boldness that will fight to correct injustice, but do so with a commitment to perseverance within the rule of law.
    

Monday, June 13, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: The Pilgrim Experiment

     One important reason to study history is to avoid the mistakes of our predecessors.  History becomes vicarious experience so that we can learn what is good and bad without suffering the consequences associated with learning by experience.  The pilgrims left us such an example. 
     In his journal of the Plymouth Plantation, William Bradford wrote that the pilgrims original design for the economy of their colony was a common store.  Each person would contribute to the colony and out of the common store, pilgrims would receive an equal share.  It was our earliest attempt at socialism.
     The colony had reached a point of continual want.  They had no more supplies and no expectation of more to come.  The leadership council, under William Bradford, began to consider how they might raise a better crop "so that they might not continue to endure the misery of want."  The solution they came to was to provide each person with land to provide for the needs of his own household.  Self-interest would provide additional incentive to work the field to provide for increase, not only for your family but the whole community.
     Before their decision, Bradford relates, there was a lot of complaining.  Women complained they could not be expected to work in the fields.  Single men complained that they did the lion's share of the work but only received one share in return. Men did not want their wives doing the laundry of single men.  Everybody did what was necessary but nothing more.
     After the decision, Bradford records the following:  "This was very successful.  It made all hands very industrious, so that much more corn was planted than otherwise would have been by any means the Governor or any other could devise, and saved him a great deal of trouble, and gave far better satisfaction.  The women now went willingly into the field, and took their little ones with them to plant corn, while before they would allege weakness and inability; and to have compelled them would have been thought great tyranny and oppression."  Everyone, prodded by self-interest, did more, profited more, and was more content.
     When the common treasure was divided among the pilgrims, everyone saw it as their duty to police the size of their piece of the economic pie.  They were not going to do more work for the same size share.  It was judged as unfair.
      When self-interest provided motivation, each worked to increase the size of their piece of the pie and it resulted in a much bigger pie.  The needs of the community were not met by equal apportionment of resources but equal opportunity to work for profit.  This fall, vote for the person who clears the way for equal opportunity rather than equal outcomes.