George Washington's Farewell Address was a gift to his nation for generations. Schools required its careful study and memorization. His address was "the disinterested warnings of a parting friend." He saw danger in the way politics was taking place in our expanding nation. He saw it as essential that we maintained our sense of unity as a people. He saw unity as a pillar of our independence, tranquility, peace, safety, and prosperity.
What was the danger to our unity? Partisanship. He was afraid that as we grew the needs of the industrial north, the agricultural south, the expanding west, and established east would conflict. Advocates would arise to protect regional interests at the expense of national unity. Today, political parties build coalitions of divergent interests in order to gain power.
"The alternate domination of one faction over another, sharpened by the spirit of revenge natural to party dissention, which in different ages and countries has perpetrated the most horrid enormities, is itself a frightful despotism," Washington wrote. Partisan dissension "agitates the Community with ill-founded jealousies and false alarms, kindles the animosity of one part against another, foments occasionally riot and insurrection."
He also saw the threat of partisanship opening the door to foreign political entanglements. Foreign influence and corruption enter the door of government itself "through the channels of party passions." Washington did not believe that partisanship provided another example of useful checks and balances to government. Instead it "would always serve to distract Public counsels and enfeeble the Public Administration." Can you effectively govern when your statesmen would rather score political victories than compromise for the sake of a united nation?
Washington wasn't finished. He believed that partisanship could so weaken a government from continuing conflict that the public would begin to "seek security and repose in the absolute power of an Individual." The leader of the winning faction could turn his eyes to promote his personal interest and his own elevation in government.
Washington ended his farewell with the desire to share, as a private citizen, "the benign influence of good laws under a free Government." This fall, elect individuals who hope to continue Washington's vision.
And your ancient ruins shall be rebuilt; You shall raise up the foundations of many generations; You shall be called the repairer of the breach, The restorer of streets to dwell in. (Isaiah 58:12)
Sunday, June 12, 2016
Saturday, June 11, 2016
2016 Voter's Guide: Is the Government Omnipotent?
Here's an experiment in political imagination: Suppose today by unanimous consent of the governed we turned over all of our rights, privileges, resources, and property to the federal government. Would our political and economic issues be solved? Would this bring about a new kind of Utopia? Would the government be able to manage our affairs in a way that would provide good provision for our physical needs, allow our children to be well-educated, and manage our needs for security, protection and healthcare?
If you had any doubt in any area that a paternalistic government was not ideal, you sensed that there are limits to what government can do. An intellectual elite, making our decisions for us, could not bring an end to war. They could not provide the satisfaction that comes at the end of a day with a job well done. They could not repair a marriage or return wayward children or end crime. They can not change the heart of man.
We ought to exhibit humility in our understanding of politics and government. There are many things that government can't do. We ought to be chastened by that fact and abandon our political hubris. When we abdicate responsibility for our own lives and the welfare of our communities by giving the government the right to control, we ask for tyranny. The one thing above all that government cannot do is be perfect. Absolute power always corrupts. Always. This fall, vote for the person who clearly recognizes that danger.
If you had any doubt in any area that a paternalistic government was not ideal, you sensed that there are limits to what government can do. An intellectual elite, making our decisions for us, could not bring an end to war. They could not provide the satisfaction that comes at the end of a day with a job well done. They could not repair a marriage or return wayward children or end crime. They can not change the heart of man.
We ought to exhibit humility in our understanding of politics and government. There are many things that government can't do. We ought to be chastened by that fact and abandon our political hubris. When we abdicate responsibility for our own lives and the welfare of our communities by giving the government the right to control, we ask for tyranny. The one thing above all that government cannot do is be perfect. Absolute power always corrupts. Always. This fall, vote for the person who clearly recognizes that danger.
Friday, June 10, 2016
2016 Voter's Guide: "With Shekels Come Shackles"
After the Revolutionary War, the federal government had a hard time recruiting exceptional candidates for federal offices. Under the Articles of Confederation, the real place to wield power and influence was the individual states. If you wished to make a difference in our new nation, you joined the state. The power of the federal government was held in check by thirteen state governments. The money which supported the federal government came from the state governments.
How much different is the political landscape today! States send lobbyists to Washington, D.C. to fight for their fair share of the economic pie. Highways and schools are built and supplied with federal dollars. State healthcare is constructed along federal guidelines. Schools were recently issued a new social guideline and then threatened with losing funds if they did not comply.
Here is the problem with amassing the resources and power at the Federal level. Government far removed from the oversight and accountability of citizens produces rules and regulations for dispensing those funds. The funds are taken from the states and localities. The funds are then lobbied for according to federal priorities. If the federal government wants to make progress in advancing some new social agenda, it needs only to tie that agenda to the distribution of funds.
The Chancellor of the University from which I graduated was fond of saying "With Shekels come shackles." When a state, locality, or individual is on the receiving end of the public dole, the government will make the rules by which you will get the money. You are no longer free to hold an opposing view. Those who choose to go another way will end up paying twice- the federal government will get their share. Your schools, roads, and healthcare will suffer for your independent thinking. You are no longer free to do what you believe is best for your constituents.
This fall, vote for those candidates who recognize a loss of freedom to the federal government. Vote for those who vow to return the freedom to the hands of the people.
How much different is the political landscape today! States send lobbyists to Washington, D.C. to fight for their fair share of the economic pie. Highways and schools are built and supplied with federal dollars. State healthcare is constructed along federal guidelines. Schools were recently issued a new social guideline and then threatened with losing funds if they did not comply.
Here is the problem with amassing the resources and power at the Federal level. Government far removed from the oversight and accountability of citizens produces rules and regulations for dispensing those funds. The funds are taken from the states and localities. The funds are then lobbied for according to federal priorities. If the federal government wants to make progress in advancing some new social agenda, it needs only to tie that agenda to the distribution of funds.
The Chancellor of the University from which I graduated was fond of saying "With Shekels come shackles." When a state, locality, or individual is on the receiving end of the public dole, the government will make the rules by which you will get the money. You are no longer free to hold an opposing view. Those who choose to go another way will end up paying twice- the federal government will get their share. Your schools, roads, and healthcare will suffer for your independent thinking. You are no longer free to do what you believe is best for your constituents.
This fall, vote for those candidates who recognize a loss of freedom to the federal government. Vote for those who vow to return the freedom to the hands of the people.
Thursday, June 9, 2016
2016 Voter's Guide: Should the Government Do Works of Charity?
It was a small, compassionate proposal. Texas had experienced a long and extensive drought that had resulted in crop failure. People were really suffering distress and destitution. As a result, congress put forth a bill to spend $40,000 to help buy seed for the farmers for the next year. The Bill (#10308, Distribution of Seeds for Texas farmers) was vetoed by the president!
What insane kind of reasoning could have possessed Grover Cleveland? Luckily, we have the text of his veto which always gave the reasoning for his decisions. In the decision, he admitted that the need was real and the proposal would effectively alleviate the distress. So, why did he choose not "to indulge a benevolent and charitable sentiment" by appropriating the funds?
Try to follow his reasoning:
It is time for us to ask ourselves some serious questions about sacrifice and charity. This fall, vote for the person who recognizes the need to support a sturdy American character.
What insane kind of reasoning could have possessed Grover Cleveland? Luckily, we have the text of his veto which always gave the reasoning for his decisions. In the decision, he admitted that the need was real and the proposal would effectively alleviate the distress. So, why did he choose not "to indulge a benevolent and charitable sentiment" by appropriating the funds?
Try to follow his reasoning:
- It was not the duty of the government nor within the jurisdiction of its power. There is a prevailing tendency, he wrote, to disregard the limited power of government and he felt it his duty to stand against it. "The people support the government, the government should not support the people."
- Individuals, churches, and civic organizations could be relied upon to answer the distress. "Federal aid in such cases encourages the expectation of paternal care on the part of the government and weakens the sturdiness of our national character," he wrote. "It prevents the indulgence among our people of that kindly sentiment and conduct which strengthen the bonds of a common brotherhood."
It is time for us to ask ourselves some serious questions about sacrifice and charity. This fall, vote for the person who recognizes the need to support a sturdy American character.
Wednesday, June 8, 2016
2016 Voter's Guide: Beware of "Manufactured" Urgency
There is a delicate balance in leadership. A leader who waits too long to make a decision is labeled "indecisive." A leader who makes decisions too quickly is "hasty" and "impetuous." Good decisions require competent evaluation and a commitment to act. Some leaders will take more time in reaching a decision than others.
One political strategy, however, is to introduce a sense of urgency into the decision-making process. When our founding fathers were trying to decide about declaring independence from Great Britain, they had several factors to consider. Poll numbers would have indicated about a third of the people were patriots, a third were Tories, and a third were undecided. As well, the cost of war against a power like England in lives and resources weighed heavy on their minds. Some, like the Quakers of Pennsylvania, were pacifists.
A little book was published early in 1776 entitled "Common Sense." It was mistakenly believed to be written by John Adams and so gained a quick notoriety. The real author, Thomas Paine, underscored the urgency of the hour. Now was the time for independence, while we had resources and before the colonists again became complacent. The little pamphlet may well have been the reason we had the energy for a revolution.
"Common Sense" was propaganda. It was clearly one-sided. It attacked the monarchy of England and highlighted America's strengths. Cooler heads may or may not have agreed with his arguments. Propaganda is like that: Pushing the agenda with an exaggerated sense of urgency.
Common in political debate today is a similar sense of urgency. The urgency is manufactured because it is easier to get a law passed when emotions are raised. Gun laws follow a massive school shooting. Declarations of War come soon after the threat of attack. Urgency can make lawmakers do foolish things.
Manufactured urgency appeals to the emotions and creates the sense that we have to do something. One recent political statement was silly with urgency: "We have to pass the bill to see what's in it!" This fall, vote for leaders who have a track record of good decision-making. Don't vote for proposals that are presented without substance but with great urgency.
One political strategy, however, is to introduce a sense of urgency into the decision-making process. When our founding fathers were trying to decide about declaring independence from Great Britain, they had several factors to consider. Poll numbers would have indicated about a third of the people were patriots, a third were Tories, and a third were undecided. As well, the cost of war against a power like England in lives and resources weighed heavy on their minds. Some, like the Quakers of Pennsylvania, were pacifists.
A little book was published early in 1776 entitled "Common Sense." It was mistakenly believed to be written by John Adams and so gained a quick notoriety. The real author, Thomas Paine, underscored the urgency of the hour. Now was the time for independence, while we had resources and before the colonists again became complacent. The little pamphlet may well have been the reason we had the energy for a revolution.
"Common Sense" was propaganda. It was clearly one-sided. It attacked the monarchy of England and highlighted America's strengths. Cooler heads may or may not have agreed with his arguments. Propaganda is like that: Pushing the agenda with an exaggerated sense of urgency.
Common in political debate today is a similar sense of urgency. The urgency is manufactured because it is easier to get a law passed when emotions are raised. Gun laws follow a massive school shooting. Declarations of War come soon after the threat of attack. Urgency can make lawmakers do foolish things.
Manufactured urgency appeals to the emotions and creates the sense that we have to do something. One recent political statement was silly with urgency: "We have to pass the bill to see what's in it!" This fall, vote for leaders who have a track record of good decision-making. Don't vote for proposals that are presented without substance but with great urgency.
Tuesday, June 7, 2016
2016 Voter's Guide: Beware of Abstractions!
"Liberty," "Equality," and "Fraternity" are great political ideas. Such words were slogans during the French Revolution. They were flags to rally the masses. The problem is the words were abstractions. They were hollow terms into which everyone poured their own personal meaning. Did equality mean the poor and the aristocracy had the same amount of power, influence, or resources? Did the guillotine help the aristocracy feel more equal? Is revolution after revolution what we meant by brotherhood? Is Napoleon what we envisioned by liberty?
Our current political discourse is riddled with abstractions. "Hope" and "Change" sounded great to those who felt the government, especially at the federal level, had not been responsive to their needs. Change has certainly come, but is it what we thought? Do you have more hope in your future now?
"Make America great again" is another abstraction. Everyone gets to fill in the blank. Nobody wants to vote against political greatness, but what do we mean by it? Every citizen worth his salt needs to follow up an abstraction with a question: What do you mean by that?
Abstractions are great for sound bites. The politician is faced with the task of winning support in a catchy sentence or two. No news organization will give a half hour to a candidate to lay out his specific ideas. Too boring. They will lose audience. So, we think we know what we are voting for, but we may be just guessing.
Voters must take their obligation as citizens seriously. Be patient to learn what your candidate, at any political level, actually believes. What does he or she intend to actually implement? This fall, vote for the candidate who has described their goals in specific, concrete ways.
Our current political discourse is riddled with abstractions. "Hope" and "Change" sounded great to those who felt the government, especially at the federal level, had not been responsive to their needs. Change has certainly come, but is it what we thought? Do you have more hope in your future now?
"Make America great again" is another abstraction. Everyone gets to fill in the blank. Nobody wants to vote against political greatness, but what do we mean by it? Every citizen worth his salt needs to follow up an abstraction with a question: What do you mean by that?
Abstractions are great for sound bites. The politician is faced with the task of winning support in a catchy sentence or two. No news organization will give a half hour to a candidate to lay out his specific ideas. Too boring. They will lose audience. So, we think we know what we are voting for, but we may be just guessing.
Voters must take their obligation as citizens seriously. Be patient to learn what your candidate, at any political level, actually believes. What does he or she intend to actually implement? This fall, vote for the candidate who has described their goals in specific, concrete ways.
Monday, June 6, 2016
2016 Voter's Guide: Does Character Matter in an Elected Official?
Some, in this heated political season, have argued that effectiveness in governance is more important in an elected official than character. Managing an organization the size of the federal government takes a special kind of skill. Experience in billion dollar budgets is more important than personal integrity.
Certainly, elected officials need the requisite leadership skills. But can those skills be divorced from the character of the candidate? Can a good leader reverse course on a promise made to his constituency if it seems to negatively affect his poll numbers? Can a good leader drive an enterprise into financial ruin as long as her own interests are protected? Will a good leader abandon the people he or she has sworn to protect?
Leadership and character are inseparable. Situations in leadership arise all the time that are unexpected and unplanned. Will your candidate address the problem with an objective standard of what is right and wrong? Will your candidate be pragmatic and follow the path of least resistance?
The only way to tell how your candidate will perform when a moral crisis arises is to check his track record. If he or she has been consistent in following an objective standard, support that integrity with your vote. If their decisions are all over the moral map, they are pursuing their own interests first and are not worthy of your consideration as political statesman.
Certainly, elected officials need the requisite leadership skills. But can those skills be divorced from the character of the candidate? Can a good leader reverse course on a promise made to his constituency if it seems to negatively affect his poll numbers? Can a good leader drive an enterprise into financial ruin as long as her own interests are protected? Will a good leader abandon the people he or she has sworn to protect?
Leadership and character are inseparable. Situations in leadership arise all the time that are unexpected and unplanned. Will your candidate address the problem with an objective standard of what is right and wrong? Will your candidate be pragmatic and follow the path of least resistance?
The only way to tell how your candidate will perform when a moral crisis arises is to check his track record. If he or she has been consistent in following an objective standard, support that integrity with your vote. If their decisions are all over the moral map, they are pursuing their own interests first and are not worthy of your consideration as political statesman.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)