Sunday, June 5, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: What is a Good Education?

     Congress recognized, in an expanding nation, that education was a vital concern.  Every territory that desired admission into the United States had to provide a means for the education of their citizens perpetually.  Why was education such a vital concern?
     The Northwest Ordinance, which set the rules for admitting territories into the union, gave three goals for education: 
          "Religion, morality, and knowledge, being necessary to good government and the happiness of mankind, schools and the means of education shall forever be encouraged."
     Two results of Education were mentioned in the Northwest Ordinance:  The happiness of mankind and good government.  The happiness of citizens and effective rule both depended on a good education.  It becomes obvious that a good education moved beyond the usual academic disciplines of reading, writing, and arithmetic to character development, civic responsibility and even worship.
      Three elements were essential to an education:  Religion, Morality, and Knowledge.  These three are conjoined.  Knowledge must be controlled by morality:  Look where science can now take us.  Is anyone concerned about the growth of technology without a corresponding growth of morality?  Morality is essentially linked to religion.  Even Rousseau saw the need for some sort of civil religion to keep the masses governable. 
     If a people can lift trustfully near their neighbor, law enforcement need only be big enough to manage the occasional squabble.  However, if a people are immoral and accustomed to mayhem, no government is large enough to keep the peace. 
     Religion is linked to both morality and knowledge.  If God created the universe, every advance in science will be "thinking God's thoughts after Him" and defining the boundaries of objective reality. Knowledge divorced from an orderly and moral Deity is subject to man's hubris and corruption.
     Man is both made in the image of God and fallen.  If a man will not be moral out of reverence for God, he may be moral out of fear of punishment.  Removing the thought of eternal judgment allows a man to pursue guilty ends believing he will get away with it.
     What does this have to do with the fall's elections?  Our culture needs to find its way back to an objective, definable morality.  Reuniting religion and morality to the academic disciplines will be a first step.  Vote for those who can see the need.

Saturday, June 4, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: How Big Should Our Government Be?

     This question spilled plenty of ink as congress debated adopting our present constitution.  Two camps formed.  The Federalists, led by James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay, believed a stronger Federal government could make our government stronger when dealing with world problems and repairs some of the weaknesses we faced in our domestic policy.  The Federalists knew the dangers of power and influence.  They proposed a collection of arbitrary checks and balances so that a growing government could be protected from ambition and lust for power.
     The other camp, represented by men like Patrick Henry and George Mason, believed that a bigger government was a threat to their individual liberties.  Patrick Henry saw his role of statesman as a kind of night watchman, whose sole purpose was to keep his eye on the precious jewel of liberty.  He was suspicious of any movement toward the jewel.  Liberty, in his mind, was more important that international prestige or prosperous commerce.  Each movement toward increasing the power of government brought a quick and fiery word from the impassioned orator. 
     Every generation should wrestle with the question of the size of government.  Every time we ask the government to take care of issues like poverty, education, and medicine, we transfer power and resources out of our hands and into the hands of government.  Who is better able to address the issues of poverty?  Individuals, local communities, churches, the state, or the federal government?  Who is better able to address the educational needs of my daughters?  Individuals, local communities, churches, states, or the federal government?  What about health and medicine?
     I can bring pressure to my local school board or city council if I want to oppose a decision they make.  I know their names and can lead an opposition in the next election.  Local candidates feel a need to respond to my interests.  Not so with the federal government.  I have much less power and influence at the level of the federal government.
     One question we must answer in the coming election is a question of freedom and paternalism.  Should government play the role of a father, making sure the needs and wants of Americans in areas like education, medicine, retirement, and welfare?  Our uncontrolled national debt is proof that this is our direction.  As a result, individuals have less money, more regulation, less freedom? 
     For example:  Suppose our taxes were not reduced but flipped!  What if most of my tax dollars went to my local government?  Would we have better roads, schools, and development?  What if the state received the same share and the federal government received what my local government gets?  In that scenario, you can see the issue clearly.  Would we have better accountability?  Better effectiveness?  It's worth thinking about.
     This fall, vote for the person who sees value in local communities and has natural suspicions when it comes to the need for a bigger government.

Friday, June 3, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: How Do We Know What Our Rights Are?


     If our rights are not arbitrary, if they are objective gifts from God, how can we know what they are?  If they are built innately into the fabric of our lives, then what are they?  This is one of many areas in which religion and politics necessarily intersect.
     In discovering our rights, theologians can argue in two ways.  The first is to read the commandments of God in reverse:  If I am not to kill, I must have a right to life.  If I am not to steal, I must have a right to private property.  If I am not to sleep with another man's wife, then I must have a right to marriage.  If we are responsible before God to behave in a certain way, then he is showing us the boundaries of our freedom.
     Theologians can also look at our creation.  In the stories of Genesis 1-3, we have a description of the reality in which man finds himself.  We are made in the image of God, so what aligns with His character is good for us and what doesn't runs against reality itself.  Creation reflects the character of the Designer.  The shape of our rights, freedoms, and responsibilities can be described by enumerating five Design Decrees:
  • Sanctity of Life.  Because man is made in the image of God, his life is special.  Murder, abortion, euthanasia, and infanticide are wrong because it is only God can give life and take it away.  Capital punishment is permitted to redress the injustice before God of taking human life.
  • Sanctity of Law.  God, by right of creation, sets the boundaries of our  actions.  Good law is in line with His decrees.  Bad law opposes it.  
  • Sanctity of Marriage.  Society has a vested interest in marriage as an essential building block of civilization.  God defines, by right of creation, marriage as a man and woman leaving their parent's home and forming a new home.
  • Sanctity of Work.  Vocation and calling are essential parts of our make-up.  The work we do is to be respected.  Work is to provide for our families and to help us understand the world around us.  Work includes all kinds of pursuits of profit and discovery.
  • Sanctity of Rest.  Man is made to rest, reflect, pursue social relationships, and to worship.  From rest we receive reflection, satisfaction and new energy for other endeavors.
     If this is the reality in which we find ourselves, then it is easy to see how our rights spring from the way we are made.  This fall vote for those who are willing to secure our rights for us.

Thursday, June 2, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: Where do we get our rights?

     Two sources have been proposed for the idea of a human right:  God and the government.  If the government grants rights, then they are necessarily arbitrary.  Your rights will be defended or withdrawn by the judgment of the government.  Rousseau believed that once a government was formed, all of your rights were given to it.  If the government at some point desired to take your life you should willingly surrender it because of all the benefits you had already received from its rule. 
     If this is the source of our rights, then force and persuasion become omnipotent.  If I want a right, all I must do, however unjust that right, is persuade 51% of people to vote my way.  If I can't persuade them, I can force them.  However, as soon as I lose power or influence, every right I have fought for can go away in favor of your opposing right.
     Jefferson wrote in our Declaration of Independence that we are endowed by our Creator with certain unalienable rights.  This means that certain rights are part of our nature, whether the government grants them to us or not.  We have a right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.  This is a way of describing our right to freedom.  We have a right to be secure in our persons, to make our own decisions and to pursue our own ends.  As moral people, we are to be free and unencumbered by others.
     Jefferson used this idea of innate human rights to explain that one purpose of government was to secure our rights for us- not give us our rights, but to make sure that we got them.  If government became a tyrant, Jefferson argues that we have a natural right to dissolve that government and to create another one that could do it better.
     When we pursue our rights, are we pursuing those given to us by God?  Our nation is pursuing new rights, civil rights, all the time.  Are these rights coming from a recognition of what God has given us by our design or are they being foisted upon us by political power and persuasion?  This fall, vote for men and women who believe human rights exist objectively as gifts from our Creator.

Wednesday, June 1, 2016

2016 Voter's Guide: What is the Purpose of Government?

     Given the political season America is currently experiencing, it would seem long overdue to revisit those principles that make for good government.  The founders believed that government is good and necessary and could serve the people of the United States well.  As long as it stayed true to its purposes, it could serve the people without abusing them.
     Those who framed our constitution said our government was designed to serve five ends:  To Establish Justice, Insure Domestic Tranquility, Provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and to secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity.
  • "To establish justice" means to make sure every citizen stands equally before the judgement bar.  Lady Justice, holding a pair of balanced scales,  was blind-folded so that justice was meted out without regard to race, wealth, or popular influence.  Justice was not seen as an advocate for the victim.  Today, Justice has then taken off her blindfold and put her hands on the scale.  She purposely adjusts the scale in order to fix social problems.  The problem is every adjustment leads to injustice for all.
  • "Insure domestic tranquility" means to aid in the process of people being able to live trustfully near your neighbor.  The role of a police force is to punish the evildoer so that the populace might live in peace.  A moral people make this job an easy, less intrusive task.  An immoral people means a greater governmental presence and intrusion.  John Adams reminds us that our way of government is not sufficient to keep the peace if we are not a moral people.
  • "Provide for the common defense" means to protect our people from enemies from without.  It is the authorization to raise a military to protect our citizens and allow them to live in peace.  
  • "Promote the general welfare" is an elastic clause that gave governmental leaders some flexibility to do what was in the best interests of all of us.  Today, every expenditure of Congress could be defended by this purpose.  However, the Framers added the word "general."  This was meant to prohibit government from pursuing the interests of some of us at the expense of others.  Rivalry between economic station or social condition was not seen as justification to break the unity between political factions.  The goals pursued under this purpose must be good for all of us.
  • "Secure the blessings of liberty" means the government is designed to rule with only as much force as is needed to keep peace.  It must take a hands-off approach in other matters not related to its purposes.  Liberty is the goal, not power, influence, or income equality.
     If the government performs its functions well, we pass freedom on to our children.  If it does not, it becomes as tyrannical as the government from which we separated.  This fall, vote for candidates who understand well what is and is not the purpose of government.

Thursday, July 24, 2014

The Limitations of Man

Did you ever stop to think about the limitations of man?  Accomplishments, Opportunities, a good dose of self-reliance, and a rugged individualism are all we need to achieve... almost anything.  Man is constantly becoming, evolving, inventing:  Who knows what we can do?
The Bible gives us a healthy dose of realism instead.  It tells us what we can't do on our own.  We are never independent of God, even in rebellion.  It's pretty humbling.  Here's a list of man's limitations:
  • Man cannot direct his own course.  "I know, O Lord, that the way of man is not in himself, that it is not in man who walks to direct his steps." (Jeremiah 10:23)
  • Man cannot provide for his own needs.  "You shall remember the LORD your God, for it is he who gives you power to get wealth" (Deuteronomy 8:18).
  • Man cannot know or trust his own heart.  The Disney princesses (and Ralph Waldo Emerson) are wrong.  "The heart is deceitful above all things and desperately sick:  Who can understand it?" (Jeremiah 17:9)
  • Man cannot even keep himself alive.  "Which of you by being anxious can add a single hour to his span of life?" (Luke 12:25)
"In Him, we live and move and have our being" (Acts 17:28).  God Himself guides us, empowers us, provides for us.  He knows our hearts.  He holds us together.  "All things were created through Him and for Him.  And He is before all things, and in Him all things hold together" (Colossians 1:16-17).

Monday, January 13, 2014

Three Strikes



Why is it so hard to trust God?  Sin makes us so short-sighted and forgetful!  Ten plagues against Egyptian oppressors ought to be hard to forget.  A divided Red Sea and the annihilation of the Egyptian army ought to secure God’s position as the central figure in all future concerns.  Daily, the Jewish people watch a visible manifestation of God’s guidance and presence among them, in the pillars of cloud and fire. 
                Yet, the Israelites were already displaying an ominous propensity to whine before God about their circumstances.  In the desert, God tested them to see what was in their hearts.  Three times preceding the events at Kadesh-Barnea, Israel complained and incurred the wrath of God:
                Taberah- Because of a “strong craving,” the people complain about their misfortunes before the Lord and God gives manna.  The Lord’s anger is also kindled and outlying parts of the camp are consumed (Numbers 11:1-9).
                Kibroth-hattaavah- The people whine for meat and God gives quail for a month (Numbers 11:19-20), “until it comes out your nostrils and becomes loathsome to you.”  The people are also struck with a plague.
                Hazeroth- God challenges the authority of those who challenge Moses, even those in Moses’ own family.  He calls Moses, Aaron, and Miriam to the Tent of Meeting and defends Moses as “faithful in all my house.”  Miriam is given leprosy and sent outside the camp for seven days in shame (Numbers 12:1-16). 

Three strikes is bad preparation for inheriting the promised land.  It signals conflict yet to come.  However, before we stand in judgment on the Israelites whining trek out of Egypt, let us examine ourselves:
1.  Do we spend more time thinking about the promises of God or the circumstances of our lives?
2.  Do our prayers have a whining quality?
3.  Do others see in our relationship with God something attractive or desirous?
4.  In what ways have I faltered before the culmination of the promises of God?
It is possible, as the passages indicate, that the judgment of God falls even on His people when they refuse to trust Him.  A final question gives me pause.  Are there signs of God’s judgment at work in my life?